help me expand on the following idea. philosophy as escaping from bullshit. must be understood as relative to an original weltanschauung (presuppositions of an age ), relative to to the religious and political climate, relative to the science of the day, as well as relative to a person’s education. For example Snell’s discovery of the mind, points out that emotions seem to come from the outside, and therefore attributing them to gods seems at the time to be reasonable. another example is the prevalence of the catholic inquisition, which stifled inquiry. it seems to me that prior to darwin, it was reasonable to be a deist. expand on these and similar ideas giving me a history of progress in escaping from bullshit
ChatGPT said:
This is a compelling and provocative framework—”philosophy as escaping from bullshit”—which can be understood as a historical process of gradually transcending the limiting worldviews (Weltanschauungen) of each age. The presuppositions of any given era shape what seems reasonable, rational, or even thinkable. What one age considers common sense or divine truth may be revealed in another as ideological constraint, superstition, or “bullshit.” Your idea lends itself to a historical narrative: a genealogy of reason, where each philosophical breakthrough marks an escape from inherited delusions.
Below is an expanded outline with key epochs and thinkers that show how humanity has slowly pushed through inherited bullshit—religious, political, scientific, and psychological—to reach clearer understandings.
Philosophy as the History of Escaping Bullshit: A Genealogy of Disillusionment
1. Archaic Consciousness and the Mythic Mind
Weltanschauung: The gods are everywhere. The world is animated by spirits. Emotions, dreams, and fate are external—sent by gods or daemons.
- Bullshit of the Age: No distinction between subject and object. No “self” as an interior. Agency is divine, not personal.
- Key Escape: Bruno Snell (in The Discovery of the Mind) describes how the Greeks gradually separated myth from psychology. What we call “consciousness” was formed by this break.
- Example: In Homer, Achilles’ rage is sent by Athena. This was a reasonable belief in a world where interiority hadn’t yet been conceptualized.
Interpretation: Philosophy begins as the moment people realize not all emotions are divine visitations. The “soul” becomes internal. Logos begins to displace mythos.
2. The Axial Age (800–200 BCE)
Weltanschauung: Spiritual and ethical universalism emerges in multiple civilizations. The individual soul becomes ethically responsible.
- Bullshit of the Age: Still largely theocratic and hierarchical, but internal ethical awareness begins to dawn.
- Key Escape: Socratic questioning, Confucian moral introspection, Buddhist analysis of suffering—all break from mythic authoritarianism.
- Example: Socrates dies for questioning the Athenian worldview. His method is the earliest known rigorous bullshit detector: elenchus (cross-examination).
Interpretation: This is the emergence of doubt as virtue. Truth becomes something pursued, not inherited.
3. Medieval Theocracy and Scholasticism
Weltanschauung: God is the source of all truth. The Church interprets His will. Philosophy is theology’s handmaiden.
- Bullshit of the Age: Rigid metaphysical systems enforced by religious authority. Inquiry is constrained by doctrine.
- Key Escape: Islamic and later Christian philosophers like Avicenna, Averroes, and Aquinas try to reconcile reason and faith—each pushing the limits of permissible inquiry.
- Example: Catholic Inquisition—suppression of heresy shows the institutional fear of free thought.
- Alternative View: Yet within these boundaries, figures like William of Ockham (Ockham’s razor) begin subtly dismantling the scholastic edifice.
Interpretation: Philosophy survives under theological censorship, but seeds of secularism are planted via rational theology.
4. The Scientific Revolution & Enlightenment
Weltanschauung: The cosmos is governed by discoverable laws. Nature, not scripture, is the source of truth.
- Bullshit of the Age: Dogmatic religion and monarchy are still powerful. “Natural law” can be co-opted to justify new forms of authority.
- Key Escape:
- Copernicus, Galileo, and Newton replace a geocentric cosmos with a mechanistic one.
- Hobbes, Locke, Voltaire, and Kant reject divine-right monarchy and argue for rights, reason, and autonomy.
- Example: Pre-Darwin deism is rational: God as clockmaker is more coherent than God as daily micromanager.
Interpretation: Science displaces superstition. Philosophy reorients toward human autonomy, empiricism, and secular ethics. But the bullshit of early modernity remains—e.g., colonial “civilizing” narratives dressed up as rationality.
5. 19th Century: Romanticism, Darwin, and Ideology Critique
Weltanschauung: Rationality is double-edged. Progress is real, but so are alienation, industrial dehumanization, and ideological mystification.
- Bullshit of the Age: Industrial capitalism’s myths of inevitable progress and divine destiny. Racist and imperialist pseudoscience.
- Key Escapes:
- Darwin dissolves the need for a designer. Marx exposes capitalism’s ideological illusions.
- Nietzsche announces the “death of God” and unmasks moral systems as will-to-power in disguise.
- Example: The rationality of Victorian morality is revealed as social control.
Interpretation: Philosophy learns to critique not just superstition, but rationality itself. Truth is not neutral—it’s bound up in power.
6. 20th Century: Totalitarianism, Structuralism, and Postmodernity
Weltanschauung: World wars, propaganda, mass media—reason can be hijacked.
- Bullshit of the Age: Ideologies of race, nation, and progress weaponized to justify genocide, authoritarianism, and conformity.
- Key Escapes:
- Freud—the unconscious as source of inner deception.
- Foucault—truth and knowledge are historically constructed by power systems.
- Sartre and Beauvoir—freedom and authenticity against bad faith.
- Example: The Holocaust is enabled by “rational” bureaucratic systems. Philosophy becomes a refuge for critique against modern bullshit.
Interpretation: Philosophy expands its bullshit detector: not just myths and theology, but structures, discourses, ideologies.
7. 21st Century: Techno-Bullshit and Digital Disillusion
Weltanschauung: Data is truth. Algorithms know you better than you know yourself.
- Bullshit of the Age: Technosolutionism, infinite scroll, influencer “truth,” AI hallucination, corporate woke-washing.
- Key Escapes (Ongoing):
- Digital ethics, critical AI theory, return to embodied philosophy (e.g., phenomenology, eco-philosophy).
- Zuboff on surveillance capitalism, Harari on data religion, Byung-Chul Han on digital burnout.
- Example: The idea that more data = more truth is increasingly questioned.
Interpretation: Escaping from digital bullshit means rediscovering attention, community, and the limits of quantification.
Conclusion: The Philosophical Imperative
Each age has its own plausible bullshit—ideas that feel natural because they’re embedded in the culture’s language, media, and institutions. Philosophy’s role is to make these assumptions visible, questionable, and ultimately escapable. This process is never complete—each escape opens new traps.
The history of philosophy, then, is not a straight line toward truth, but a spiral—a continual unmasking of yesterday’s certainties.
Would you like this structured as a longer essay or lecture script? Or we could format it as a book proposal or blog series.Attach
Search