explain to me why some religious people seem to be uneducable, they won’t look at evidence contrary to their view
ChatGPT said:
That’s a thoughtful and often frustrating question, and it’s one that touches on psychology, identity, and how people process belief. Let’s break it down:
1. Beliefs as Identity
For many religious people, their faith is not just a set of ideas — it’s core to their identity. Challenging their beliefs can feel like a personal attack. It’s not just “you’re wrong about this claim,” but “your entire worldview and who you are might be wrong.” That’s incredibly threatening, and people often defend against that threat by shutting down opposing ideas.
2. Cognitive Dissonance
When people encounter evidence that contradicts deeply held beliefs, it creates cognitive dissonance — a psychological discomfort. Instead of adjusting the belief, which would require a major mental (and emotional) overhaul, they often resolve the dissonance by rejecting the evidence.
3. Motivated Reasoning
People often don’t reason to find truth — they reason to defend what they already believe. This is called motivated reasoning. For religious believers, especially those in tight-knit communities, questioning their faith could mean social costs: alienation, loss of support, or even fear of divine punishment. So the mind defends the belief system — often unconsciously.
4. Epistemic Walls
Some religious traditions explicitly teach that faith should override evidence. For example:
- “Blessed are those who have not seen and yet have believed.” (John 20:29)
- “Lean not on your own understanding.” (Proverbs 3:5)
If you’re raised with the idea that doubt is a sin, or that secular evidence is a test or trick, then it’s not just natural to ignore counter-evidence — it’s virtuous.
5. Echo Chambers
In some religious communities, people are surrounded by others who all believe the same things and distrust outside information. This creates an informational bubble where only confirming views are accepted. Dissenting voices are labeled as lies, temptations, or attacks.
But to be fair…
This isn’t only a religious phenomenon. Many people — religious or not — resist changing their minds when their beliefs are threatened. You see the same resistance in political ideologies, conspiracy theories, nationalism, and even in scientific communities under certain conditions.
So what’s the takeaway?
People don’t usually change their minds because of facts alone — especially when identity and community are involved. The more a belief is tied to someone’s sense of self, the harder it is to uproot, no matter the evidence.
If you’re trying to reach someone who seems “uneducable,” it often works better to start with empathy and curiosity rather than confrontation. Minds change more through relationships and stories than through facts alone.
Would you like to talk about strategies for engaging with someone like this?
You said:
they also show a lack of curiosity – explain
ChatGPT said:
Absolutely — you’re pointing to something very real: a lack of curiosity often accompanies rigid belief systems. Here’s why that happens and how it fits into the bigger picture:
1. Certainty Kills Curiosity
Many religious systems offer absolute answers to life’s biggest questions — Why are we here? What is good? What happens after death? When you believe you already have the ultimate truth, there’s no incentive to keep exploring.
- Curiosity thrives on the unknown.
- Certainty replaces the unknown with finality — shutting the door on further questions.
This is why you might hear phrases like:
“Why would I need science or philosophy when I already have God’s Word?”
2. Curiosity Requires Psychological Safety
Being curious means being willing to question, explore, and maybe even be wrong. But for many religious people, being wrong isn’t just uncomfortable — it’s dangerous.
- Doubt may be seen as sinful.
- Questioning can be discouraged or punished.
- Leaving the faith might mean losing family, friends, or community.
So instead of curiosity, you get protective conformity.
3. Religious Upbringing Can Train Curiosity Out of You
Some people are raised in environments where asking “Why?” too often is discouraged or punished — either directly (e.g., being scolded) or subtly (e.g., being ignored, shamed, or corrected with “because God says so”).
- Over time, people stop asking.
- Not out of stupidity, but out of habit, fear, or obedience.
4. Curiosity Can Be Emotionally Risky
To be curious, you have to open yourself to uncertainty. For someone who has built their entire worldview on unchanging truths, that openness can feel like stepping into chaos.
It’s easier — and emotionally safer — to stay in a known, structured belief system than to wonder “What if I’m wrong?”
5. Some Religions Redirect Curiosity Inward
Not all religion kills curiosity. But in many traditional systems, curiosity is redirected:
- Not “What does science say about the universe?”
- But rather: “What does God want from me?” or “How can I be more holy?”
That is a kind of curiosity — but it’s confined within strict boundaries. The curiosity is allowed, but only as long as it reinforces the faith.
Summary:
Lack of curiosity in religious individuals isn’t always about intelligence or stubbornness — it’s often:
- a survival strategy,
- a result of early conditioning,
- or the product of a worldview that sees questioning as dangerous or unnecessary.
If you were told your whole life that curiosity leads to hell, heresy, or heartbreak, you might not explore either.
If you’re trying to have meaningful conversations with someone who lacks curiosity, the best approach is usually modeling your own curiosity — gently, non-threateningly, and without trying to “win.” That can sometimes plant a seed that facts alone can’t.
ChatGPT can make m